From what I read, I believe that the editor of Planet Muscle, Jeff Everson, was downplaying the idea that an average person, who is not training or eating right, can just slug down some carnitine and lose fat. This is probably true, but a product like Lean Out is in an anti-fat category by itself and I bet even Mr. Everson would acknowledge this. Lean Out sure helped me.
You might erroneously conclude that L-Carnitine is ineffective if you did not use enough of the utmost quality carnitine. Our Lean Out contains the quality and content to do the job against fat.